Kawai saboda su duka suna da 360 a cikin sunan, ba yana nufin cewa sun kasance iri ɗaya ba, wanda shine kuskuren gama gari. A cikin wannan shafin yanar gizon, zan kwatanta Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336 (wanda shine babban Excavator) don ganin ko akwai bambance-bambance da kuma lokacin da ya kamata ku zaɓi ɗaya akan ɗayan. Fitowar wannan kwatancen kuma zai ƙunshi fa'idodi da rashin amfani.
Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336 Excavators | Dipper
A yau muna duban na'urori biyu, Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336 Excavators | Dipper. A cikin wannan bidiyon, za mu kalli aikin dipper na kowace na'ura. Dipper yana ɗaya daga cikin sassa mafi wahala na aikin tono don haka yana da mahimmanci a san yadda suke yi.
Cat 336 ya kasance tun daga 2009, yayin da Komatsu kwanan nan ya sake fasalin PC360 kuma ya sake shi a cikin 2017. Don haka zai zama mai ban sha'awa don ganin yadda suke kwatanta.
Don wannan gwajin mun yi amfani da guga ton 7 akan injinan biyu. mun duba yadda suke saurin cika guga, yadda suke yi da guga mai cike da sauri, sannan da saurin zubar da kaya.
| Komatsu PC360 | Kashi 336 | |
| Tsawon Dipper - Mafi ƙarancinft/ in | 10 ft 5 in | 9 ft2 in |
| Tsawon Dipper - Mafi Girmaft/ in | 13 ft 2 in | 12 ft 10 in |
Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336 Excavators | Layin tuƙi
Dukansu Komatsu da Cat sanannun suna ne a masana'antar kayan aiki masu nauyi, amma suna ɗaukar hanyoyi daban-daban don ƙirar haƙa.
Komatsu PC360 yana ba da zaɓi mai matsakaicin girman tono don ƴan kwangila waɗanda ba sa son injuna babba akan wuraren aikinsu. Wannan ya sa ya zama kyakkyawan zaɓi don ayyukan da ke da sasanninta da yawa ko kunkuntar wuraren shiga.
Komatsu ya tsara su PC360 tare da ergonomics a zuciya, wanda ke nufin cewa ya fi dacewa ga masu aiki suyi amfani da dogon lokaci. Taksi ɗin ya ɗan fi girma fiye da nau'ikan gasa, wanda kuma yana taimakawa wajen sa masu aiki su kasance masu fa'ida.
PC360 ba shi da iyawa iri ɗaya kamar wasu manyan injuna, don haka bai dace da manyan ayyukan tono ba. Amma girmansa ya sa ya dace da ƙananan wuraren gine-gine inda kake buƙatar motsa wasu datti ba tare da samun hanyar sauran ma'aikata suna yin ayyuka daban-daban ba.
Ana samun Cat 336 Excavator a cikin saiti biyu. An fara gabatar da samfurin E Series a cikin 2008 kuma ya kasance sananne a yau saboda har yanzu ana tallafawa.
| Komatsu PC138 | Katon 314 | |
| Ƙimar fitar da iska | Darasi na 4 | |
| Mai kera injin | Komatsu | Cat |
| Adadin Silinda | 6 | 6 |
| Inci Matsala³ | 540 | 568 |
| Fitar injin - Net hp | 257 | 311 |
| Bi Nisa inci Takalma | 33.5 | 24 |
Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336 Excavators | Girma
Wannan shafin yana kwatanta girma da ƙayyadaddun bayanai na Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336 Excavators.
Mun tabbatar da nuna muku bayanin a cikin sauƙin karantawa gefe-da-gefe tsarin kwatanta. Da fatan za a raba wannan shafin ga abokan ku.
Abu mafi mahimmanci da za a yi la'akari da shi lokacin siyan excavator shine sanin ko zai dace ko a'a a wurin aikin da kuke da shi. Wannan shine dalilin da ya sa muka sauƙaƙa muku a nan ta hanyar ba ku duk ainihin girman kowane injin tono gefe da gefe.
| Komatsu PC360 | Kashi 336 | |
| Tsawon Sufuri - Matsakaicin ft/in | 12 ft 4 in | 12 ft 2 in |
| Tsawon Sufuri - Sama da Boom ft/in | 10 ft9 in | 11 ft 4 in |
| Gabaɗaya Tsawon Ƙarƙashin Karu ft/in | 16 ft 3 in | |
| Sifili Tailswing | A'A | A'A |
| Dozer Blade | ||
| Nisa akan tsayayyen waƙoƙi | 11 ft 3 in | 10 ft 5 in |
| Track Gauge ft/in | 8 ft 6 in | 8 ft5 in |
| Tono zurfin-2.24m/8ft lebur kasa ft/in | 23 ft 7 in | 24 ft |
| Front Slew Radius - Mono Boom ft/in | 14 ft 2 in |
Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336 Excavators | Ƙarfi
The Komatsu PC360 excavator yana da matsakaicin zurfin tono ƙafa 21 da inci 5. Tsawon albarku shine ƙafa 13 da inci 9.
The Cat 336 excavator yana da matsakaicin zurfin haƙa na ƙafa 21 da inci 2. Tsawon haɓakar ya kai ƙafa 15 da inch 1.
Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336 Excavators | Injin Wuta
Komatsu PC360 yana da ƙarfin ƙarfin injin dawakai 200. Matsakaicin ruwa na hydraulic shine galan 17.9 ko lita 68 a minti daya. The man fetur iya aiki ne 183 galan ko 693 lita.
The Cat 336 yana da wani engine ikon rating na 225 horsepower. Matsakaicin ruwa na hydraulic shine galan 15 ko lita 57 a cikin minti daya. The man fetur iya aiki ne 142 galan ko 536 lita.
Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336 Excavators | Girman jigilar kayayyaki
Komatsu PC360 yana auna ƙafa 35, faɗin inci 3 da ƙafa 13, tsayin inci 8. Wannan injin hakowa yana auna kusan fam 75,200 ko kilogiram 34,149 tare da madaidaicin guga da aka makala.
| Komatsu PC360 | Kashi 336 | |
| Gallon Tankin Mai (Amurka) | 159.8 | 158.5 |
| Na'ura mai aiki da karfin ruwa Tank galan (US) | 49.7 | 42.5 |
Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336 Excavators | Ayyuka
The Komatsu PC360-10 excavator matsakaici ne zuwa babban na'ura tare da injuna mai ƙarfi kuma fiye da isasshen iko don ɗaukar yawancin ayyuka. Komatsu ya yi suna tare da injunan dogararsu da saman fasahar layi. Duk da yake suna ɗaya daga cikin ƙananan kamfanoni a cikin masana'antar gine-gine, har yanzu suna yin wasu mafi kyawun injuna da kuɗi za su iya saya.
The Cat 336 excavator babbar na'ura ce mai ƙarfi wacce ke da ikon sarrafa ko da mafi girman ayyuka. Cat 336 Excavator ya kasance a kusa da shekaru da yawa yanzu kuma ya tabbatar da kansa ya cancanci a kira shi "sarkin" na tono.
Abubuwan haɗin samfuran biyu sun haɗa da:
● Cikakken abin farin ciki na lantarki wanda ke bawa mai aiki damar sarrafa duk ayyuka daga wurin zama
● Albarku, sanda da guga waɗanda duk an yi su daga ƙarfe mai ƙarfi don tsayin daka
Haɗe-haɗen babban yatsan yatsan ruwa na zaɓi don ɗaukar abubuwa ko ɗaukar duwatsu
● Taksi da aka ɗora akan bushings na roba don rage rawar jiki da matakan amo
Sauran fasalulluka na Komatsu PC360-10 sun haɗa da:
● Ƙananan hayaƙi Tier 4 Zaɓin injin ƙarshe (in ba haka ba shi ne Tier 3) wanda ke rage yawan mai da kashi 10% yayin da rage fitar da iskar gas zuwa kashi 20% idan aka kwatanta da na baya.
| Komatsu PC138 | Katon 314 | |
| Matsin Ƙarƙashin Ƙasa PSI | 6.9 | 9.9 |
| Swing Speed rpm | 9.5 | 8.75 |
| Tractive Force lbf | 65191 | 66206 |
| Dipper Tearout lbf | 38360 | 37300 |
| Bucket Breakout lbf | 51150 | 47160 |
| Dago - An nakalto da Guga? | A'A | A'A |
| Jimlar Gudun galan (US) / min | 141.3 | 147 |
Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336 Excavators | Nauyi
Nauyin Komatsu PC360 da Cat 336 excavators ba su da yawa daban-daban, da bambanci ne game da 5-10 ton. Yawan Komatsu PC360 shine ton 26, yawan Cat 336 shine ton 24.
Bugu da kari, na'ura mai aiki da karfin ruwa excavator Komatsu PC350LC-8 sanye take da Kobelco SK350 guga da damar 1.9 m3, aiki nauyi 23.23 ton, guga breakout karfi 156 kN da engine ikon 135 kW / 184 hp. Nauyin aiki na Caterpillar 336EL hydraulic excavator shine 30,200 kg kuma ikon injin shine 179 kW / 241 hp…
| Komatsu PC138 | Katon 314 | |
| Nauyin Aiki | 79807 | 81900 |
| Ma'aunin nauyi | 15255 | 14991 |
Zaɓi Komatsu PC360 vs Cat 336
Waɗannan injina guda biyu suna da alaƙa da yawa. Dukansu an gina su ne don ayyukan gine-gine masu nauyi kuma duka biyun suna aiki da injin iri ɗaya, C7.1 daga Caterpillar.
Amma akwai bambance-bambance tsakanin samfuran, ciki har da girmansu gaba ɗaya da nauyinsu, na'urorin lantarki, fasalin fasaharsu da ƙari. Yayin da masu siye tare da alamu da yawa sukan yada aikin auro.
